Hawk the Slayer-A film that is a lot better than you remember it because of all the little things it does so well but, if we're being honest, is still a little undercooked in too many important spots to be considered truly 'great'. At its core, it's a boiler plate fantasy adventure about revenge and on the surface isn't very well shot, has hokey sound design, substandard action, laughable effects and uneven performances by the film's two leads: John Terry is practically dead as title character Hawk and Jack Palance devouring scenery as his brother and the film's heavy Voltan neither balance or cancel each other out but there are so many little parts to this flick that elevate it above the hokey schlock of the day (in my opinion.)
Probably the most remarkable things about the movie are the acting (pretty stellar across the board except the film's two main characters) and the grit of world itself, including the costume design in many cases. The dialogue is super smart at points, witty and clever in its banter and delivered with expert grace by much of the secondary cast and the bit characters that are on screen merely to serve as foils to the more central players. Some of the dialogue in these scenes bordered on Game of Thrones tier repartee when that show was at its sardonic best. When I was a kid and I watched this, I couldn't appreciate just how grounded and expertly written these small exchanges were but as an adult, seeing it with much older eyes, it's plain to me that there are some fantastic exchanges going on. i could watch an entire 'slice of life' movie in this world if all of its inhabitants talked like this.
Some of the supporting cast are absolutely stellar. Peter O'Farrell understands his assignment as the wisecracking dwarf Baldin, who doesn't really do much more than makle jokes and trick people before sacrificing himself to buy the rest of the heroes a little more time. He's funny and comes off as someone that survives more because he's the smartest guy in the room than because of any rugged qualities, and his interplay with the giant Gort (fantastically brought to life by Bernard Bresslaw) is so much fun to watch. Bresslaw has most of the best scenes in the film and he carries every moment he's in. The one handed soldier Ranulf, played by William Morgan Sheppard, feels like the most 'real' character in the movie and he delivers most of his lines with such gravity that I found myself legitimately believing in him. Even Ray Charleson's monotone elf Crow, who seemed so bad to me when I first saw it, is....well, okay it's still bad. But I think he did a good job, at least, of making himself distinct from the rest of the cast. Regardless of what you think about the performance, it's still memorable and unique from the rest of the group. Not sure what he was going for here but it doesn't break my immersion the way it used to. And the subplot with the nun that actually believes Voltan will make good on his promise to return the mother superior character to the convent after the ransom is paid is very well seeded throughout the movie and a believable plot twist when her betrayal plays out.
This film is something I'd consider a 'near miss'. It was this close to being respectable and I can't help but think that with a little more money, a little more time. a little better direction of its leads and a little bit of a helping hand on the production, it could have been up there with the true giants of 80s fantasy films, Conan the Barbarian, Excalibur and Dragonslayer. As it is, Hawk the Slayer has to settle for being in the upper B tier of the genre. Which, considering how much barbarian slop came out in the 80s, isn't he worst place to be.
3 out of 5. It does enough of the little things very well and kept me engaged this time around.