WWE Night of Champions PLE Results: 5-27-23
Results courtesy of
PWTorch.com (direct link to Keller's complete report)
(1) A.J. STYLES vs. SETH ROLLINS – World Hvt. Title match
(Putting this match on first immediately puts it at considerable risk of seeming as secondary as the old World Title did when was the opening match title while the WWE Title belt main evented. It defines it down as a secondary title. That said, the argument internally within WWE is that going on first is the second most prestigious position on their events if the match has high stakes.)
Cole and Graves talked about the design of the new belt and it being an homage to past titles. Seth made his entrance as fans sang his theme song. After formal ring introductions, Cole said this is the first world title match in more than four years, and the last time Styles lost to Seth. The bell rang 13 minutes into the hour. Seth continued to act as a conductor as the fans continued to sing his song. They were about to do a test of strength, but Seth pulled away to play to the crowd. A frustrated Styles dropkicked him to jump-start the action. Graves said that was a surprising mistake by Seth given the stakes.
Styles battled back and took Seth down with a step-up enzuigiri. Graves said both men are such perfectionists and came prepared for each other, so the outcome could come down to one mistake. Styles set up a Styles Clash from the top rope, but Seth escaped and then took control in the opposite corner. Styles elbowed free, but Seth came right back with his own inverted DDT off the top rope followed by a side slam for a near fall at 12:00.
Seth blocked a Phenomenal Forearm attempt and knocked Styles to the floor. Seth dove to the floor at Styles, but came up limping. Cole said Seth appeared to tweak his knee. Back in the ring, Styles applied a Calf Crusher mid-ring. Seth rolled out of it, but Styles reapplied it. Seth escaped by shifting into chinlock so Styles broke. They replayed the Seth landing in slo-mo and observed the moment on the landing where it appeared Seth tweaked his knee. Seth caught Styles with a quick clothesline. Both were down and slow to get up. They showed the new belt on a table at ringside.
When Styles went for a Phenomenal Forearm again at 19:00, Seth kicked him out of mid-air. When Seth went for a stomp, his knee buckles and collapsed. Styles then rolled Seth into position for a Calf Crusher, but Seth slipped free and landed a Pedigree followed by a stomp for the three count.
Triple H entered the ring and presented Seth with the belt as Seth’s music played.
WINNER: Rollins in 20:00 to become the World Hvt. Champion. (****)
(Right in the zone of what you’d expect from these two at this stage of their careers, with a smartly crafted story in the match and an economy of meaningful big moves and countermoves with a lot of effective body language selling the intensity early and the grind late in the match. No surprise at all that Seth won, and I can understand from the standpoint of ending this event with more suspense and drama, putting this on somewhere other than last. If you buy the idea that the opening slot is prestigious, then this was a fair placement of the match when looking the layout of this show. It still, though, risks defining it down out of the gate as secondary to whatever Roman Reigns or Brock Lesnar are doing, title or no title.)
(2) TRISH STRATUS vs. BECKY LYNCH
A video package aired on this match before ring entrances. As Trish made her entrance, Graves asked Cole if he has thanked her lately. Cole said he doesn’t understand why she needs to talk about her past like she does. Graves said she got tired of not being talked about enough so she wants to show this generation she’s the greatest of all time. Cole said when he retires, “you’ll never hear from me again.” (That might’ve gotten the biggest pop of the night so far from some people watching at home.) Becky walked out in a yellow jump suit and black stripes and a black zipper. (That can’t be fun to wrestle in, but it’s cool looking.) Cole said Trish made a critical error dragging Becky’s young daughter into the conversation because it just ticked her off. Graves agreed because Becky is dangerous enough otherwise.
The bell rang 47 minutes into the hour. Becky went on the attack right at the start and stomped away at Trish in the corner. Trish threw Becky into the ringside steps. Trish landed a tornado DDT back in the ring for a two count. Trish yanked on Becky’s mouth and then slammed her head to the mat. Graves said Trish has a professional respect for Becky’s skills. Cole laughed at the timing of the comment. Cole said Becky admits she isn’t perfect but is proud of her accomplishments. Cole noted Trish hasn’t had a singles match in over four years. Graves touted her fitness routine including yoga.
Trish set up a superplex at 7:00, but Becky blocked it. Trish remained in control and set up a Stratusfaction, but Becky countered. Becky then went on the attack and landed a legdrop off the second rope for a two count at 9:00. Trish set up a sharpshooter, but Becky blocked it and climbed to the top rope. Trish went for a top rope head scissors, but Becky countered into a Boston crab off the ropes.
At ringside, Becky leaped off the ringside steps toward Trish, but Trish roundkicked her out of mid-air. Back in the ring, Trish landed a Chick Kick for a two count. Trish slapped Becky. Becky immediately lunged and applied a Disarm Her. Trish yanked on Becky’s hair to escape. They stood and brawled. Becky ducked a kick and then rolled up Trish for a two count. She followed with an immediate Alabama Slam and made the cover. Trish put her leg on the bottom rope to stop the ref’s count. When Trish retreated to the floor, Becky went after her and threw her back into the ring. Zoey Stark came out from under the ring and yanked on Becky’s leg and then delivered her Z360 knee to the gut. She threw Becky into the ring where Trish landed a Stratusfaction for the win.
Cole called it a hit and run and wondered what that was all about. Stark celebrated with Trish afterward. Becky’s nose was bleeding pretty heavily afterward. She wasn’t bleeding until after the Stark attack at ringside. It wasn’t obvious if it was the Stark move or the Stratusfaction that caused the bleeding.
WINNER: Stratus in 15:00.
(Good match. They were ambitious with the length of the match, and they had the crowd involved and invested at various times, but not consistently relative to the opener. Trish is back in a good groove, though, and Becky is a great opponent to be part of a good singles match. Zoey getting to align with Trish is going to elevate her quickly, especially as it appears she’ll be feuding with Becky next.)
(3) GUNTHER vs. MUSTAFA ALI – Intercontinental Title match
Graves downplayed Ali’s chances. The bell rang 11 minutes into the second hour. Gunther landed a chop early, but Ali fought back with a flurry of kicks. Gunther went for a quick sleeper, but Ali escaped and landed two dropkicks to the chin. Gunther bodyslammed Ali a second later, then landed several chops to the chest. Fans booed as Gunther gloated. Gunther settled into a crossface mid-ring. Cole said Gunther has no wasted motion and just gets to business. Graves said he’s all substance with his smash-mouth style.
At ringside, Gunther threw Ali into the ringpost and then re-entered the ring. Cole said some people compare Gunther to Bruno Sammartino. Gunther looked around as he battered Ali. Cole said Gunther believes the IC Title is the most prestigious championship. Graves said the rest of the roster is watching Gunther, and Gunther knows it. Ali showed fire with a comeback at 5:00. He delivered a leaping neckbreaker and then climbed to the top rope. Gunther chopped him off the top rope and then attempted a double underhook suplex. Ali blocked it and delivered a sunset bomb. “The champ’s in trouble,” Cole said. Ali leaped off the top rope with a 450 splash and scored an near fall that popped the crowd.
Gunther went back on the attack and landed a hard clothesline. Cole said the 450 might’ve been the last gasp for Ali. Seconds later, Ali made another comeback and landed a tornado DDT and went for another 450. Gunther moved and then landed a dropkick and a powerbomb into a stack pin for the win. Graves called Gunther a “dream crusher.” Cole said he might be the most dominant in the history of WWE.
WINNER: Gunther in 9:00 to retain the IC Title. (**3/4)
(Good story that allowed Ali to put up a great fight while also allowing Gunther to remain in the mode of the dominant champion.)