Garou is more fun of a fighting game, it's easy to pick up the whole cast are easy to get into. The just defend system and other mechanics are enjoyable. Third strike on the other hand is more refined and is harder to master. Outside of it's superior graphics the game itself is more strict on button inputs for combos and the parry system can create a huge gap between pro's and newbs. I personally feel like we can't compare the games. It's like comparing a local spot to a high end restaurant, its not the same quality of food. I took a break from video games during covid times due to life in general and I recently played both games and realized I forgot how to play em. Third Strike feels like a chore to me now but Garou was still fun. Back in the day i'd say third strike was better because I had the time and energy and arcades were still a thing. But now i'd rather play Garou. I don't have the patience to relearn and my old ass lost the necessary reflexes for parrying.