i voted in Gears 3. i'm a Gears of War fanboy, always been. i think the new campaign sucks big time, but the multiplayer is stellar. Nowadays i don't have the time to sink into long SP games.or the will. so i need something immediate, and Gears multi delivers that need in its various multiplayer modes, specially in Deathmatch where i spend the most time.also its a great splitscreen game and i love to play Local multiplayer with my wife and friends.So this has been my most played game this year along Street Fighter 4 AE and Deathsmiles Pal.
If i buy Zelda next month i'm sure that will be the only thing i'll be playing.
I think you should consider Bulletstorm. the best FPS i played in a long time. Fast and not to big campaign, amazing visual and art,guns, enemies etc. this is the kind of game i would dream off,when i was a kid. Great celebration of videogame culture.