- Joined
- Sep 6, 2005
- Posts
- 12,919
As some her may or may not know, SW is a religion for me. Sadly, much of my "religion" is fan writings. The SW universe is amazing and like others have said, for once I have HIGH hopes for the franchise now that Disney has taken it over.
Lucas has done amazing things, but much of his movies aren't part of that legacy. I've said it before but EP I-III are train wrecks full of horrible storytelling, CG jerk offs and some of the worse dialog you'll, heave this side of an indie film.
It has a few necessary plot elements but Lucas managed to fuck the story up so badly, it needs to be mostly forgotten.
Concerning the Anakin plot however...I don't consider it to me inadequate in the slightest. A crybaby, two dimensional ass hat with amazing powers loses control of himself and manages to destroy much of the Jedi order? I can buy that. The problem is, although realistic (think of how many shit heads are currently in power), it doesn't make for a an entertaining story. The story of Luke, Leia, Han Solo and the supporting cast are FAR more interesting than that of a asshole who turns to the dark side.
This point and JJ Abrams are why I have hope. He managed to reboot another piece of sacred ground damn near flawlessly (sans lense flares). He stepped in and managed to perfectly re cast a story many thought couldn't be done. I mean James T Kirk...William Shatner...there was only one Kirk, until now. The same goes with Bones and Spock but he managed to do it.
I have faith that he can recast Luke, Leia and Solo. If he can do it to Star Trek, he can do it with SW. The cool part is that there is an ocean of stories that can be told to further the franchise.
Lucas has done amazing things, but much of his movies aren't part of that legacy. I've said it before but EP I-III are train wrecks full of horrible storytelling, CG jerk offs and some of the worse dialog you'll, heave this side of an indie film.
It has a few necessary plot elements but Lucas managed to fuck the story up so badly, it needs to be mostly forgotten.
Concerning the Anakin plot however...I don't consider it to me inadequate in the slightest. A crybaby, two dimensional ass hat with amazing powers loses control of himself and manages to destroy much of the Jedi order? I can buy that. The problem is, although realistic (think of how many shit heads are currently in power), it doesn't make for a an entertaining story. The story of Luke, Leia, Han Solo and the supporting cast are FAR more interesting than that of a asshole who turns to the dark side.
This point and JJ Abrams are why I have hope. He managed to reboot another piece of sacred ground damn near flawlessly (sans lense flares). He stepped in and managed to perfectly re cast a story many thought couldn't be done. I mean James T Kirk...William Shatner...there was only one Kirk, until now. The same goes with Bones and Spock but he managed to do it.
I have faith that he can recast Luke, Leia and Solo. If he can do it to Star Trek, he can do it with SW. The cool part is that there is an ocean of stories that can be told to further the franchise.