I should qualify - I’ve got a few HD cabs which I replaced the monitors with modern monitors in. I also think playing at a cabinet is ideal for a couple reasons: 1. Control height, and 2. Stability - if you’re grinding out a clear on a shooting game, it’s imperative that your stick isn’t moving all over the damn place. This is non-negotiable, and I consider the number of clears I’ve bagged on my cabs proof of these things. If you can account for the proper height and stability though, a nice standalone stick with a PC and fast monitor is fine.
I still have a lot of nostalgia for and fond memories of the old CRT candy cabs, I just lost the desire to own any of that stuff anymore.