I'm surprised to learn that Princess Bride has a fanatical following. My mom really likes that movie, and I saw it a decent number of times when I was little, but I didn't know people were crazy for it (although now that I think about it, a large number of my friends have seen it and apparently liked it quite a bit).
I'm not sure if I would have liked these movies if it weren't for the fans, but these were movies I saw because people always talked about how awesome they were, and when I finally saw them, I didn't enjoy them:
Fight Club
Superbad
The Hangover
It isn't a movie, but I don't understand why people go ape shit for Cowboy Bebop. I watched the whole series (minus the movie) probably 6 years ago now. I liked it enough to watch the whole thing, but I don't understand why people think it's "THE BESTEST SHOW EVAH!" Is it just the Final Fantasy 7 effect?
*Hides before he's stoned to death *